| 2017 | |
| Ryan Kutt | University of Illinois |
| Ryan King | Michigan State University |
| Jack Guzek | Indiana State University |
| Andy Lopez | Saint Joseph’s College |
| 2016 | |
| Michael Massey | University of Illinois |
| Andrew Dyke | University of Illinois |
| Dylan Rusniak | University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| Ryan Gorman | Loras College |
| Joey Preusser | South Suburban College |
| 2015 | |
| Michael Schalasky | University of Indianapolis |
| Danny Paluch | Loras College |
| Jake Petraitis | St. Mary’s University (Minnesota) |
| Tom Przekwas | Moraine Valley Community College |
| 2014 | |
| Kevin Biondic | Maryland |
| Kevin Sullivan | Middle Tennessee State University |
| Michael Enriquez | Parkland Community College |
| Ian McGinnis | Illinois-Wesleyan |
| Brian Musielak | Concordia (Illinois) University |
| Kyle Hilliard | Concordia (Wisconsin) University |
| Jake Barry | St. Mary’s (Minnesota) |
| 2013 | |
| Wendall Ferguson | Clafflin University |
| Luke Liebforth | Loras College |
