| Bob Defries | 1967, Chicago White Sox |
| Lou Pasierb | 1969, California Angels |
| John Pasierb | 1969, Kansas City Royals |
| Jim Michal | 1969, Minnesota Twins |
| Pete Mackanin | 1969, Washington Senators |
| Mike Redden | 1972, Pittsburgh Pirates |
| Ray Crowley | 1975, Montreal Expos |
| Scott Meyer | 1978, Oakland Athletics |
| Bob Cummings | 1978, San Francisco Giants |
| Joe Piechota | 1979, Montreal Expos |
| Jim Adduci | 1980, St. Louis Cardinals |
| Bob Ritchey | 1982, California Angels |
| Bill Kazmierczak | 1986, Chicago Cubs |
| Don Harlan | 1987, Kansas City Royals |
| Bill Judge | 1988, Chicago Cubs |
| Rich Polak | 1989, New York Yankees |
| Andy Stemler | 1991, Cleveland Indians |
| C.J. Keating | 1995, Los Angeles Dodgers |
| Ryan Quinn | 1997, San Diego Padres |
| Anthony Albano | 2001, Minnesota Twins |
| Mike McQuillan | 2012, Washington Nationals |
